North America's Premier International Resort Community

Vail Police Identify Suspects in Theft Investigation

  • 11 June 2020
Vail Police Identify Suspects in Theft Investigation

The Vail Police Department has identified the two suspects involved in the theft of a vehicle and two high-end mountain bikes at the Fall Ridge Condominiums in April.  Arrest warrants have been issued for Kathrine Elizabeth Steele, 29, of Englewood, and David Daniel Boyle, 42, of Westminster.

On April 27, two individuals were captured on surveillance video entering the condominium complex in East Vail. They left with two mountain bikes valued at $3,300 each and stole a 2019 Ford Ranger truck belonging to a resident of the complex. After numerous weeks of investigation, the Ford Ranger was recovered in Englewood. At the time of the truck’s recovery, the female suspect was identified and located in Englewood. After being interviewed, the investigation alleges Steele committed the thefts from Fall Ridge Condominiums, as well as a burglary that occurred in Vail in November 2019. The suspect was also implicated in numerous other crimes in both Eagle County and the Front Range area after a search warrant was conducted on the recovered Ford Ranger. 

Steele was not taken into custody at the time of her interview because her charges did not meet the COVID-19 requirements at the jail.   

Through further investigation, the male suspect, Boyle, was also identified and has yet to be located at this time. The two bikes stolen from Fall Ridge Condominiums have not been recovered.

The arrest warrants issued for the two suspects include charges for 18 felonies and 5 misdemeanors, including theft, aggravated auto theft, burglary, possession of financial devices and identity documents, and conspiracy.

Anyone with information regarding this incident is asked to contact Detective Lachlan Crawford, 970-479-2134 or the Vail Police Department at 970-479-2200. All information can be made anonymously.

All persons are presumed innocent until proven guilty in the court of law. 


  • Gallery

Theme picker